Skip to main content
Menu
teen girls hanging out together

Mel White Parent Coach

Why Fixing Teenagers Doesn’t Work — And What Parents Can Do Instead

If you’ve ever looked at your teenager and thought, “What on earth is going on in your mind?”, you’re not alone. Despite having more resources, experts, and programs than ever before, young people today are facing record levels of depression, anxiety, and other mental health struggles. So why aren’t the usual strategies working? And more importantly, what can help? In a recent conversation on my podcast - Your Parent Coach with therapist, researcher, and author Will Dobud, we explored why “band-aid” solutions fail, why labels can sometimes do more harm than good, and how parents can shift their perspective to truly support their teens.

The Problem With Quick Fixes

Over the past few decades, we’ve seen an explosion of parenting books, best-selling guides, and mental health programs. But the outcomes for teenagers haven’t improved. Why? Because many of these solutions are built on false assumptions and oversimplifications. Easy fixes like banning phones or pushing kids into rigid programs often ignore the root causes of distress. Diagnostic tools frequently over-pathologize normal adolescent struggles — for example, the most common depression screening tool has a 65% false positive rate. Labels, while sometimes offering short-term relief, can become identities that lower self-esteem in the long run. As Dobud explains: “We need to treat young people as crew — not passengers. If we just wait for experts to ‘fix’ our kids, we’re missing the fact that there’s already a capable, incredible young person in front of us.”

Rethinking Youth Mental Health

Instead of focusing only on treatment after problems escalate, prevention and connection must become the focus. Decades of research tell us the same thing: whether it’s prevention or intervention, what helps young people thrive is consistent. Caring relationships with adults who listen and show up. Safe spaces where they feel seen and respected. Autonomy — opportunities to make choices, learn responsibility, and grow resilience. These aren’t quick fixes. They’re everyday practices.

Labels, Identity, and the Risk of Overdiagnosis

One of the most powerful insights from Kids These Days: Understanding and Supporting Youth Mental Health (Dobud & Harper, 2025) is that our mental health system often relies too heavily on labels. While diagnoses can provide validation, they can also become limiting identities. For example, the youngest children in classrooms are statistically most likely to be diagnosed with ADHD — raising the question: are we medicalising immaturity? Labels, if internalised, may narrow a teen’s self-perception instead of empowering them. Parents often feel overwhelmed by these labels, asking: “How do I deal with my child’s diagnosis?” Instead, the shift is to see the whole child beyond the label.

The Power of Curiosity

In my own work as a parent coach, I’ve found that one of the most effective tools is curiosity. Instead of rushing to correct, diagnose, or fix, I encourage both parents and teens to get curious about each other. What’s really going on behind the behaviour? What unmet need is being expressed? What’s working well that we can do more of? Curiosity invites openness, respect, and collaboration. It builds connection where disconnection usually grows.

One Simple Strategy To Try This Week

If you’re a parent feeling stuck, here’s a simple yet powerful practice you can start immediately: Keep a notebook for one week. Write down every positive thing you notice about your teen — no matter how small. From emptying the dishwasher, to checking in with a sibling, to showing a moment of kindness — these little signs are evidence your child is moving in the right direction. By shifting focus to what’s working, you create more opportunities to grow positive behaviours instead of only reacting to problems.

Final Thoughts

Teen mental health is complex, but the solution doesn’t lie in more diagnoses, stricter rules, or “fixing” teenagers. Instead, it’s about meeting them where they are, offering curiosity instead of judgment, and remembering that every young person is capable of growth when given the right support. If you’re ready to shift the way you parent and support your teen, check out: Kids These Days: Understanding and Supporting Youth Mental Health by Will Dobud & Nevin Harper (available September 30) & visit my website www.melwhiteparentcoach.com for parenting programs, support and 1:1 sessions. Let's walk beside teens with curiosity and care.

Report

Woman writing in a journal
For Writers & Storytellers

Your voice
can inspire a
generation.

Share your personal story, perspective, or expertise with thousands of readers looking for real voices and real experiences. Your words can change someone's path.

Personal EssaysCareer StoriesLife LessonsAdvice Columns

Send us feedback

Thoughts, ideas or something that is not working? Tell us. The page you are on is sent with your message.